Death or Glory: Memories of the Sword movie review

August 28, 2015 at 6:05 am Leave a comment

Lee in snow, Memories of the Sword, 2015

Lee in snow, Memories of the Sword, 2015

A new South Korean action movie is usually a cause for celebration in my house and after the trifecta of ass-kicking historicals last year (The Pirates; Kundo: Age of the Rampant, and The Admiral: Roaring Currents) I was looking forward to seeing Memories of the Sword, which opens this weekend in North America. As a big Lee Byung-hun fangirl, I mean, scholar, I’m also happy to see one of my favorite actors in a genuine starring role after suffering through his supporting roles in a string of mediocre Hollywood movies (GI Joe 1 & 2; Red 2, and Terminator: Genysis). And since LBH’s last historical film, Masquerade, was outstanding, I had high hopes for this new one. Alas, Memories of the Sword is no Masquerade, and doesn’t stand up to the big three historicals from last year either.

I should’ve known that things were amiss when Memories took forever to be released. Although it began production in 2013 and was completed in 2014, the film has languished for many months due to a salacious blackmailing scandal involving LBH (who’s married) and a couple of younger women. That tawdry episode concluded earlier this year with prison sentences for the two women.

So despite a big-name cast that also includes Jeon Do-yeon (The Housemaid) and Lee Junho from boy band 2PM, the bloom is off the rose as audience buzz for this one has died down to a murmur. But the film has other flaws that make this one more of a miss than a hit.

Fighting, Memories of the Sword, 2015

Fighting, Memories of the Sword, 2015

Right off the bat the film throws down the wire-fu gauntlet as young swordswoman Hong-Yi (Kim Go-eun) leaps many feet over a tall sunflower, then bounds high in the air across a grassy field. Following a swordfighting competition that she enters in drag, Hong-Yi encounters Yu-Baek (LBH) who is intrigued by her martial arts skills. The film then follows a convoluted narrative of betrayal, ambition, revenge, and concealed identity involving Hong-Yi, Yu-Baek, and Hong-Yi’s foster mother Sul Rang (Jeon Do-Yeon).

Although the movie possesses the usual sheen and polish of South Korean commercial movies, the film is burdened by a vastly overcomplicated plot and a dour overall demeanor. Everyone has something to hide and the angst is laid on pretty thick as characters weep regretfully while slashing and stabbing one another. The interlocking interpersonal relationships recall the intricacies of Ang Lee’s Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon minus Lee’s poeticism and his strong sense of narrative rhythm, and in fact the film resembles CTHD in its costuming, its scenes of fights in bamboo forests, and its complicated court intrigue.

Yet Memories is missing Ang Lee’s masterful touch, as the film’s characters repeatedly explain their motivations and relationships to one another through long, anguished speeches or angry outbursts. Not much is left to subtlety or suggestion, yet the film still manages to bog down in confusing plot details. It’s not helpful either that most of the characters have two names and identities, which is not a spoiler in any way.

Chopped, Memories of the Sword, 2015

Chopped, Memories of the Sword, 2015

Lee Byung-Hun as usual cuts a commanding figure as the ambitious Yoo-Baek, and Jeon Do-Yeon is her expressive and emotive self. The younger actors, Kim Go-eun and Lee Junho, are also fine, though Lee doesn’t have a lot to do. Kim is convincing as the young swordswoman driven to vengeance by forces outside of her control and it’s nice to have a female protagonist in a martial arts movie. But the film feels murky and overly serious, with a leaden sense of import that drags down the story. Some of the images are quite lovely, including a beautiful swordfighting scene in a field of pale, feathery grasses, but too often the movie falls back on clichés like the metallic ringing of a sword drawn from its sheath that’s repeated a few too many times. In addition, when their demise would be inconvenient to the plot, several of the main characters have the death-defying ability to survive seemingly fatal sword wounds.

It’s always fun to see the lavishness of a South Korean movie on the big screen but with Memories as well as last month’s Assassination, both films feel a bit overstuffed. In both cases the over-the-top aesthetic of South Korean commercial cinema works to each film’s detriment, smothering any sense of artistry or nuance under a blanket of glossy emptiness.

Memories of the Sword, dir. Park Heung-sik

opens Fri. Aug. 28, 2015

AMC Metreon 16

135 4th St Suite 3000, San Francisco, CA 94103

Entry filed under: korean movies, lee byung-hun, memories of the sword, movies. Tags: , , , .

Addicted To Chaos: Ringo Lam’s Wild City film review Can I Kick It? An Interview with Legions of Boom author Oliver Wang

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed


supported by

Blog Stats

  • 452,431 hits

Archives

tweetorama

  • RT @DrJenHo: I resemble this tweet 4 hours ago
  • RT @Amylouioc: Fantasy is when Irish words are randomly thrown into conversation and Sci-Fi is when all street signs are in Japanese hope t… 7 hours ago
  • RT @SonyaChildress: Still floored that the only coverage of the layered critique of the film came from tweets and quotes from essays, but n… 7 hours ago
  • RT @assuss: smh at the mendacity of this NYT article accusing indy Muslim filmmakers of “censoring” a white woman while omitting the chief… 7 hours ago
  • RT @naushero: Read this 🔥 thread instead of the @nytimes 🗑 “article.” 7 hours ago
  • RT @Scarbble: Y'all, seriously. Since i've seen this going around *again*: Literally nobody is going to pass out drugs at halloween disguis… 9 hours ago
  • RT @quatoria: Friends, I think you know who benefits when we don't demand that our workplaces invest in our protection, when we don't deman… 10 hours ago
  • RT @quatoria: They want you to feel helpless, and defeated, and like you would require a one-in-millions mutation to avoid COVID-19. And… 11 hours ago
  • RT @quatoria: They talk about "superdodgers," and mutations. They talk about people who "don't get symptoms." They want you to think that i… 11 hours ago
  • RT @quatoria: I don't have some kind of genetic mutation, I've just never been unmasked in an indoor space or in outdoor crowds. I don't se… 11 hours ago
  • RT @MTA_Calendar: This week also marks 8 years since the beginning of the Umbrella Revolution in Hong Kong. Students led a strike against… 19 hours ago
  • RT @SLeoChiang: “When the song was over, fans loudly chanted ‘We are Hong Kong’.” 1 day ago
  • RT @naushero: This! This! This! 👇🏽👇🏽👇🏽 1 day ago
  • RT @jasonfitzroy: Not reposting it, but that new article from the newspaper of record about “Jihad Rehab” ain’t it, if only for how reducti… 1 day ago
  • RT @lisalmn: This NY Times story misses the mark and focuses on the filmmakers whiteness, when there were so many other ethical issues- que… 1 day ago

%d bloggers like this: